Upgraded away from the xcarve

The x-carve has been an amazing machine, and a significant learning experience; however, looking forward at the capabilities of the new machine I picked up I am very excited about the range of things I can possibly make.

I picked up a Fine Line Automation Saturn 2 4x4, this is an amazing machine. The gantry is all steel, 25mm linear rails, trammable spindle plate on the z-axis. The machine is crazy heavy, almost 600lbs!

This is the table I build to hold the beast

Picking it up from the local Fedex Freight terminal

Had to borrow a friend’s engine hoist to get it on the table

A few months back I had picked up some closed loop nema 23 steppers with controllers, now I just needed to hook them up and run wires.

Now to do tuning and testing

3 Likes

For those interested here is the link to the machine: https://www.finelineautomation.com/products/saturn-2-series-cnc-router-4-x-4?taxon_id=54

So Chris, what made you decide on this machine versus a cnc router pros or a similarly priced / designed machine? Did you put hands on this machine before purchase?

I was actually looking at the CNC Router Parts 4x4 machine when I found this one. There were 3 main points that sold me on this machine over CNCRP

  1. All steel frame, especially the gantry.
  2. The base machine comes with a few things that are extras on the CNCRP machines, like the trammable z axis plate.
  3. Price, this machine was almost $1000 less than the CNCRP Pro

I had not put my hands on it, I ready quite a bit about the machines and the work Nate has put into them for refining small issues in the previous design when he came out with the Saturn 2. The base design philosophy of the machine is a CNCRP clone, he even uses a number of their items in his electronics packages.

LOL I have a CNCRP PRO 4896 maybe I should looked into this one before I bought mine

looks interesting I like that its all steel

The first run on the Saturn series still had an aluminium gantry, this is the second version with the steel, was just released about a month ago.

are those the nema 23’s that you went with?

and it looks like they are using the CNCRP type rack and pinion drives

These are the nema 23’s, I got them from Aliexpress, I think they were like $90 each including the controller.

I think they make the drives themselves,but you are correct, same style. The racks are a lot thicker than the pro series though.

ahh I see yeah I have the nema 34’s on mine and I have yet to stop those puppies looking to go to clearpath digital servos pretty soon though

but yeah I would be interested to see what feeds and speeds you get out of that machine and also what kind of edge finishes you achieve with the steel machine

with the 23’s I have the x-axis running 1,000 IPM rapids, and it felt like the motors were barely trying hard.
steps per mm were within .02mm

lets run that bad boy about .75" into baltic birch and feed at 750 ipm and see where we are at then lol

1 Like

Well, at least I do not have to worry about axis flex!!1!

very true I have been looking at either a

shop saber
Legacy
or
a cnc factory python xpr machine

but idk I might look into one like you got there as just a smaller machine for small jobs I wish they made a 4x8 though

He has a 4x8 coming in November.

https://www.finelineautomation.com/articles/2017/9/15/introducing-the-saturn-2

oh dang maybe I need to give those guys a call

thanks

I am pretty sure the guy that owns the company has a full time day job, so he tends to return calls after he gets off work, and sometimes it takes him a day or two to get back to you. As long as you know that going in, he is a cool dude to work with and super smart.

oh yeah need to have a chat with him it sounds like

but I just saw that there plug and play electronics are CNCRP electronics

that kinda sucks because CNCRP electronic are over priced imo

Yeah, I build all of my own electronics and still came ahead of the plug and play.

1 Like

that machine is quite alot more quite than my linear rail machine