Dust Shoe: X-Carriage-mounted or Z-axis mounted?

I got 2 different models 3d printed. I’ve been using the “original” Makita dust show with great success. Biggest complaint is you have to take it off to change the bit which is a huge pain - especially if you need to change in the middle of a job. I have not tried the fixed version yet, but that would “fix” the bit change issue (no pun intended).

-Tom